18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition

534 Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition the Ordinance violated the Equal Protection Clause because it burdened “fundamental rights, cannot pass strict scrutiny, and has no rational basis.” Id . at *15. Defendants contended the Ordinance was an economic regulation that easily passed rational basis review, and that strict scrutiny did not apply. Under a rational basis review, the Court found that the Ordinance’s "purported purposes" were to "protect and promote the public health, safety, and welfare" and that the Ordinance benefited both grocery workers and the public during a time when much was uncertain. As such, the Court found that the Ordinance did not violated the Equal Protection Clause. For these reasons, the Court granted Defendants’ motion to dismiss in its entirety. Cassell, et al. v. Snyders, 990 F.3d 539 (7th Cir. 2021). Plaintiffs, a Christian church and its pastor, filed a class action seeking a preliminary injunction against the now-expired 10-person limit on religious and other gatherings that Illinois imposed by the Governor in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The District Court denied the motion, and on appeal, the Seventh Circuit affirmed the District Court’s ruling. Plaintiffs contended that Executive Order 10, which imposed the 10-person limit on religious gatherings, violated their right to exercise their religion under both the First Amendment and the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act, violated their due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment, and exceeded the Governor’s powers under the Illinois Emergency Management Agency Act and the Illinois Department of Public Health Act. Id . at 542. Executive Order 10 prohibited public gatherings of more than 10 people, with limited exceptions for certain essential activities, but not religious gatherings. Prior to Plaintiffs’ appeal to the Seventh Circuit, the Governor issued Executive Order 2020-38, which encouraged a 10-person limit on religious gatherings, but removed the mandate. The Seventh Circuit explained that parties seeking a preliminary injunction must demonstrate not only likely success on the merits, but also that they would suffer irreparable harm if preliminary relief was denied. The Seventh Circuit determine that Plaintiffs no longer faced any live threat of enforcement, and all subsequent executive orders had consistently refrained from limiting the free exercise of religion. The Seventh Circuit opined that the most recent order repeated the free exercise exemption and stated that the Governor going forward did "not intend to rescind these exemptions during the disaster proclamations issued due to COVID-19." Id . at 546. The Seventh Circuit further observed that recent U.S. Supreme Court authority indicated that equitable considerations weighed against granting a preliminary injunction at this time, when the prospect of irreparable injury to Plaintiffs was very low. Additionally, the Seventh Circuit determined that the public interest factors weighed against injunctive relief. Id . at 550. The Seventh Circuit opined that Plaintiffs’ federal procedural due process claim was not presented to the District Court, and the state law claims presented serious jurisdictional concerns such that the remaining claims were unlikely to succeed on the merits. Id . at 551-52. For these reasons, the Seventh Circuit affirmed the District Court’s ruling denying the motion for a preliminary injunction. Children ’ s Health Defense, et al. v. Rutgers, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 184242 (D.N.J. Sept. 27, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of university students, filed a class action seeking declaratory relief that Defendant’s mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy was unconstitutional. Plaintiffs sought a temporary restraining order (“TRO”), which the Court denied. Plaintiffs contended that Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905), requires a mandatory vaccination to be reasonable, necessary for public health, and proportional to the needs for public safety. Id . at *4. Plaintiffs argued that Defendant’s policy was inconsistent with Jacobson , and therefore was unconstitutional because it mandated vaccination for students who might not even go onto the campus, and therefore would not further Defendant’s interest in furthering public safety. Plaintiffs further asserted that Defendant would not be injured by an injunctive order requiring it to follow its own policy to exempt from its vaccination requirement those students who were fully remote, since they would not physically come to campus for coursework. As to public interest, Plaintiffs cited the public’s general interests in safeguarding constitutional rights and in requiring public institutions to adhere to their own stated policies. Defendant argued that Plaintiffs could not demonstrate that their claims were likely to succeed on the merits. Defendant contended that similar suits challenging vaccine mandates had failed on the same grounds. Defendants further asserted that any challenge to the constitutionality of the policy should also fail, as the exemption from the vaccine policy was only for fully-remote online degree students, which did not apply to Plaintiffs. The Court found that Plaintiffs had not met their burden that they were likely to succeed on the merits. The Court explained that although Plaintiffs had rights to informed consent and to refuse unwanted medical treatment, these rights were not absolute. The Court further determined that it was for the legislature, not the judiciary, to determine what modes of protection would likely be effective against the vaccine, and given the severity and deaths associated with the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a real and substantial relation between Defendant’s vaccine policy and the

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4