18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition

Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 535 need to protect public health. The Court also concluded that Plaintiffs were not fully remote within the context of Defendant’s system. The Court determined that there was no evidence that Plaintiffs would suffer irreparable harm or injury in the absence of a preliminary injunction. The Court also found it reasonable that Defendant might suffer administrative harm if injunctive relief was granted, as it would be required to develop and adopt policies and make new procedures to accommodate Plaintiffs whenever they were on campus. For these reasons, the Court denied Plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction. Chung, et al. v. Carnival Corp., 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 149147 (C.D. Cal. Aug. 9, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of cruise ship passengers, filed a class action alleging that Defendant’s negligence contributed to an outbreak of COVID-19 aboard its cruise ship. Plaintiffs asserted that prior to their boarding the cruise ship, Defendants had experienced COVID-19 outbreaks on other vessels and yet boarded passengers without conducting "any effective medical screenings for passengers and without providing any additional information about best practices to mitigate or prevent the spread of COVID-19." Id . at *5. Plaintiffs contended that despite knowing about COVID-19, Defendants "did not alter their on-ship protocols, event itineraries, or cleaning or disinfectant practices," nor "provide passengers . . . any information about COVID-19." Id . On February 19, 2020, Defendants allegedly became aware of a passenger suffering from COVID-19 symptoms onboard a ship " but did not alert Plaintiffs nor "put into place any quarantine requirements" or other similar protocols. Thereafter, over 100 persons on the ship contracted COVID-19 and at least two died. Plaintiffs alleged that if they "had known the serious and actual risks of contracting or spreading COVID-19," Plaintiffs would not have sailed on the cruise. Id . at *6. Defendants filed a motion to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6), which the Court granted. Defendants contended that Plaintiffs failed to plausibly allege actual or constructive knowledge that sailing on February 11, 2020 was a risk creating condition or that Defendants’ measures to contain an outbreak during the voyage would prove to be inadequate. Id . at *7. Second, Defendants argued that Plaintiffs failed to allege "concrete, harmful symptoms of COVID-19." Id. at *8. The Court concluded that the alleged risk-creating condition was not unique to the maritime context, as any crowded place or location with compromised individuals could be significantly risky during the COVID-19 pandemic. In assessing the sufficiency of Plaintiffs’ allegations of actual or constructive knowledge of the risk-creating condition, the Court determined that Plaintiffs’ allegations were sufficient to plausibly demonstrate that Defendants knew or should have known that COVID-19 posed a threat to its passengers. The Court therefore declined to dismiss Plaintiffs’ negligence claim on that basis. However, the Court found that for the three Plaintiffs who only alleged fear of contracting the virus and resulting emotional distress, they could not pursue negligent infliction of emotional distress claims because exposure to the virus did not result in "immediate risk" of physical harm. Id. at *11. In addition, Defendants argued that Plaintiffs lacked standing to seek injunctive relief because Plaintiffs did not allege that they would ever travel on a Princess cruise ship again or that any future conduct would cause injury to Plaintiffs. The Court agreed with Defendants, as Plaintiffs specifically stated that they would not cruise again on Princess. Accordingly, the Court granted in part and denied in part Defendants’ motion to dismiss. Church, et al. v. Biden, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 215069 (D.D.C. Nov. 8, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of 18 federal employees and two active-duty Marines, filed a class action alleging that the U.S. Department of Defense’s mandatory COVID-19 vaccine mandates violated their constitutional rights. Specifically, Plaintiffs contended that the mandates: (i) infringed on their First Amendment right to the free exercise of religion; (ii) contravened the Religious Freedom Restoration Act ("RFRA") by "substantially burdening" their "sincerely held religious beliefs," which compel them to abstain from receiving any COVID-19 vaccine; (iii) violated their Fifth Amendment right to equal protection; and (iv) violated the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act ("FDCA"), by failing to provide them the "option to accept or refuse administration" of a product available under emergency-use authorization. Id . at *16. Plaintiffs sought emergency injunctive relief preventing the mandates’ enforcement. The Court denied the motion. The Court noted that each Plaintiff requested an exemption to the COVID-19 vaccine mandates they challenged, which were still pending. The Court determined that Plaintiffs did not face any disciplinary action for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine. The Court opined that Plaintiffs’ alleged injuries therefore rest on hypothetical predictions of the outcomes of their exemption requests, but the "mere potential" for future injury was insufficient to "render an issue ripe for review." Id . at *27. As a result, the Court ruled that Plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that any injury was "imminent" or "certainly impending," and therefore have not carried their burden. Id . at *28. For these reasons, the Court denied the motion for an emergency temporary injunction.

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4