18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition
Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 533 at *25. For these reasons, the Fifth Circuit granted Plaintiffs’ motion for a stay pending judicial review of the Mandate. Burcham, et al. v. City Of Los Angeles, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 213359 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of 13 Los Angeles Police Department employees, filed a class action against Defendants alleging constitutional and statutory violations related to Defendants’ COVID-19 vaccine mandate. Plaintiffs filed an application for a Temporary Restraining Order ("TRO”), and the Court denied the motion. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Mayor of Los Angeles signed Los Angeles City Ordinance No. 1871342 (the "Ordinance"), mandating that City employees be "fully vaccinated for COVID-19, or request an exemption, and report their vaccination status . . . no later than October 19, 2021." Id . at *1. The exemptions were for medical conditions or sincerely held religious beliefs. Plaintiffs argued that, up to the filing date of the TRO Application, Defendants never provided employees with a process for submitting exemption requests. Id . at *2. Defendants asserted that they had an outlined process, that they had not rejected any exemption requests, and had no taken no adverse employment action related to the requests. Plaintiffs’ proposed TRO would order Defendants to: (i) immediately activate an online portal and/or designate a specific delivery point for written accommodation requests; (ii) cease requirements that employees use the designated "Religious Exemption Form" and "Religious Accommodation Certification Form;" (iii) cease the requirement that an employee may only qualify for a medical exemption if they had a contraindication to the COVID-19 vaccine; and (iv) prohibit Defendants from taking adverse employment action against employees until their exemption requests had been fully considered. Id . at *6. Plaintiffs asserted that without the requested relief, they would suffer irreparable harm, and they would be forced to choose between receiving a vaccine or facing an adverse employment action. Id . The Court determined that Plaintiffs had not carried their burden of showing irreparable harm as to a purported lack of online submission portal, particularly where all of them successfully submitted their own notices of intent and received claim forms. Id . at *7-8. In addition, the Court noted that the City was accepting religious exemption requests in any form, had not denied any exemption requests, and had taken no adverse employment action against any employees. As to the medical exemption request, the Court reasoned that Plaintiffs failed to present any evidence that Defendants had taken, or likely will take, negative action on medical exemption requests without considering all submitted information. Finally, the Court held that Plaintiffs’ fourth request was premature, as all those waiting for exemption application approval were still provided with the exemption while it was pending. The Court concluded that Plaintiffs could not establish a likelihood of imminent, irreparable harm and it denied the TRO application. California Grocers Association, et al. v. City Of Long Beach, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 149162 (C.D. Cal. Aug. 9, 2021). Plaintiffs filed a class action alleging that Defendants’ passage of the Premium Pay for Grocery Workers Ordinance ("Ordinance"), which provided $4.00 of premium pay per hour for grocery store employees due to the COVID-19 pandemic, was constitutionally invalid. Defendants filed a motion to dismiss, which the Court granted. Plaintiffs asserted five causes of action, including: (i) that the National Labor Relations Act ("NLRA") preempted the Ordinance; (ii) that the Ordinance violated the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution; and (iii) California Constitution; and (iv) that the Ordinance violated the Contracts Clause of the U.S. Constitution; and (v) the California Constitution. Defendants moved to dismiss on the grounds that Plaintiffs failed to state a claim pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6). As to the first cause of action, Plaintiffs contended that the NLRA preempted the Ordinance, due to its effect of squashing any possible collective bargaining between parties. Defendant contended that the Ordinance was a substantive labor standard and still permitted collective bargaining and thus there was no preemption. The Court concluded that the Ordinance affected all employees, union and non-union equally, such that it had no impact on the collective bargaining process. The Court noted that the Ordinance was therefore simply a minimum labor standard not subject to preemption because it did not impinge collective bargaining mechanisms. Id . at *8. Thus, the Court dismissed the preemption claim. Plaintiffs also contended that claims the Ordinance violated the Contract Clause because it impaired existing collective bargaining agreements and did not serve a significant or legitimate public purpose. Id . at *9. Defendants asserted that the Ordinance provided grocery workers premium pay furthered a significant and legitimate public purpose. The Court ruled that Plaintiffs failed to show substantial impairment or disprove any legitimate purpose. The Court explained that the Ordinance was a valid exercise of the police powers to serve a significant and legitimate public purpose. Id. at *13. The Court determined that the compensation for the hazardous conditions grocery workers were placed in due to the pandemic was a legitimate purpose. Finally, Plaintiffs asserted that
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4