18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition

532 Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment because Plaintiffs had a property interest in their pay; and (ii) the Mandate violated their statutory and contractual rights, as Plaintiffs had a right to have charges proffered against them and have a hearing before "discipline" by either N.Y. Education Law § 3020-1, N.Y. Civil Service Law § 75, or the applicable CBA. Id . at *5. The Court found that Plaintiffs failed to establish success on the merits because all the named Plaintiffs had until November 30, 2021, to avail themselves of the procedures for requesting accommodations and exemptions, and opting to extend their leave without pay status through September 5, 2022. Further, the Court reasoned that after receiving multiple notices regarding the Vaccine Mandate and after being notified of the applicable dates, procedures, and consequences regarding continued non-compliance with the Mandate, Plaintiffs could still have sought relief through an Article 78 proceeding in the New York State Supreme Court, which would provide a sufficient post-deprivation remedy. Id . at *24. The Court thus reasoned that Plaintiffs had multiple avenues available to them to challenge and address the actions taken against them as a result of the Vaccine Mandate through the procedures established in the CBAs governing the terms of Plaintiffs’ employment, through grievance and arbitration procedures, and undisturbed, well-established state law procedures. Id . at *24-25. As to whether Plaintiffs would be irreparably harmed absent an injunction, the Court agreed that a loss of income was a hardship, but in order to justify an injunction Plaintiffs must identify a harm for which available legal remedies and monetary damages would be inadequate. The Court noted that should Plaintiffs prevail, monetary relief would be available to compensate their loss of income, and thus injunctive relief was not warranted. Finally, the Court opined that both the balance of equities and the public interest disfavored the injunctive relief requested by Plaintiffs. Id . at *28-29. On balance, the Court concluded that the equities at stake and the importance of safeguarding the public health and safety, and the public interest weighed in favor of denying the preliminary injunction. Id. at *29. For these reasons, the Court denied Plaintiffs’ motion. BST Holdings, LLC, et al. v. OSHA, 2021 U.S. App. LEXIS 33698 (5th Cir. Nov. 12, 2021) . Plaintiffs, a group of employers, states, religious groups, and private citizens, filed a class actions and moved to stay and permanently enjoin Defendant from enforcing its Emergency Temporary Standard (the "Mandate") requiring employees of covered employers to undergo COVID-19 vaccinations or take weekly COVID-19 tests and wear a mask, pending full judicial review of the Mandate. The Fifth Circuit granted the stay. The Fifth Circuit recognized that Plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits because the OSHA was not created with the intent to authorize a workplace safety administration to make sweeping pronouncements on matters of public health affecting every member of society. Id. at *8. Further, the Fifth Circuit noted that even if the Mandate was deemed constitutional, it was fundamentally flawed because it was both over-inclusive (applying to employers and employees in virtually all industries and workplaces in America) and under-inclusive (purporting to save employees with 99 or more co-workers from a "grave danger" in the workplace, while making no attempt to shield employees with 98 or fewer co-workers from the very same threat). Id . at *9. The Fifth Circuit determined that the Mandate grossly overstated the OSHA’s authority. The Fifth Circuit explained that it was unclear that COVID-19 posed the kind of grave danger that § 655(c)(1) contemplated, i.e. , the kind of emergency that allows the OSHA to take the extreme measure of an Emergency Temporary Standard. Turning to the necessity of the Mandate, the Fifth Circuit reasoned that it was sweepingly overbroad and that OSHA would be better to approach providing guidance in way tailored to specific business and industries. The Fifth Circuit opined that the Mandate appeared to be a "poorly-suited approach for protecting workers” against COVID-19 “because no standard that covers all of the Nation’s workers would protect all those workers equally." Id. at *19. In addition to the over-inclusive nature of the Mandate, the Fifth Circuit determined that the under-inclusive nature of the Mandate implied that the Mandate’s true purpose was not to enhance workplace safety, but instead to ramp up vaccine uptake by any means necessary. Id . at *20. The Fifth Circuit also observed that the Mandate likely exceeded the federal government’s authority under the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution because it regulated non-economic inactivity falling squarely within the States’ police power. Id . at *22. Accordingly, the Fifth Circuit concluded that the arguments against the Mandate showed a great likelihood of success on the merits. The Fifth Circuit determined that absent a stay, Plaintiffs would be irreparably harmed, whether by the business and financial effects of a lost or suspended employee, compliance and monitoring costs associated with the Mandate, the diversion of resources necessitated by the Mandate, or by the OSHA’s plan to impose stiff financial penalties on companies that refused to punish or test unwilling employees. Id . at *24-25. The Fifth Circuit ruled that the public interest would also be served by maintaining our constitutional structure and maintaining the liberty of individuals to make intensely personal decisions according to their own convictions. Id .

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4