18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition

Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 93 allegations regarding waitstaff payments were also flawed, as he did not assert that he knew the amount any waitstaff employee was paid. The Court thereby granted in part Plaintiff’s motion for conditional certification of a collective action. Headly, et al. v. Liberty Homecare Options, LLC, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 102425 (D. Conn. June 1, 2021). Plaintiff, a live-in home caregiver, filed a collective action alleging that Defendant failed to pay overtime compensation in violation of the FLSA. Plaintiff filed a motion for conditional certification of a collective action, which the Court denied. Plaintiff sought conditional certification of a collective action consisting of all home caregivers who had worked at least one in-home overnight shift. Plaintiff contended that pursuant to her contract with Defendant, she was entitled to eight hours of sleep of which five hours must be uninterrupted and was also entitled to meal breaks during the day. Plaintiff alleged that she regularly worked through her meal breaks, and had to wake up during sleep time almost nightly to attend to her clients. When she began her employment with Defendant, Plaintiff attested that there was no way to report interrupted breaks on her timesheet, and instead employees had to call into the main office to report any interruptions. Defendant revised its timesheet templates in April 2018, at which time employees were able to indicate whether a break was interrupted. Plaintiff asserted that if interruptions were recorded, it sometimes resulted in a delayed paycheck. Plaintiff further contended that she was aware of other caregivers who experienced similar issues. Defendants opposed the motion on the grounds that Plaintiff was not similarly-situated to the membership of the proposed collective action. The Court agreed with Defendants’ position. It found that Plaintiff failed to allege that all home caregivers were subject to a common policy in violation of the FLSA. The Court noted that the only common policy or practice that Plaintiff identified was the failure to accurately record hours worked including interruptions of sleep or break time. The Court opined that having a poorly designed timesheet did not violate the FLSA, and nothing about the timesheet was unlawful on its face. The Court concluded that Plaintiff did not allege that she or others recorded their hours accurately on their timesheets but were denied overtime pay. Therefore, the Court ruled that Defendant also failed to allege that Defendant knew or should have known that their caregivers were not receiving their required breaks. Id . at *12. The Court observed that the only allegations in the complaint or Plaintiff’s declaration were conclusory allegations that other caregivers had their sleep and meal breaks interrupted or that Defendants had notice of those interruptions. Accordingly, the Court denied Plaintiff’s motion for conditional certification of a collective action. Hernandez, et al. v. NHR Human Resources LLC, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 115242 (S.D.N.Y. June 18, 2021). Plaintiff, an apartment building superintendent, filed a collective and class action alleging that Defendant failed to pay overtime compensation in violation of the FLSA and the New York Labor Law. Plaintiff filed a motion for conditional certification of a collective action on his FLSA claims, which the Court granted. Plaintiff sought conditional certification of a collective action consisting of all current and former superintendents, porters, handymen, and maintenance workers employed at any of Defendants’ buildings. In support of his motion, Plaintiff offered his own declaration that outlined his work experience, personal observations, and discussions with co-workers that they were not paid for overtime compensation. The declaration also averred that superintendents were on-call all day and would hours of “after work” to perform, but were instructed by their manager to document that they worked only 40 hours per week. Id. at *20. Plaintiff also named four other superintendents who he alleged would desire to opt-in to the collective action. Defendants argued that conditional certification should be denied because Plaintiff relied solely on conclusory allegations based on his "observations" and "conversations" with co-workers. Id . at *22. The Court held that the details in Plaintiff’s declaration make the requisite showing at the conditional certification stage to establish that similarly-situated individuals existed. The Court ruled that Plaintiff also provided sufficient evidence that Defendant had a policy of not compensating employees for actual time worked, but only for time reflected in timesheets that were known to have been inaccurate, which violated the FLSA. For these reasons, the Court granted Plaintiff’s motion for conditional certification of a collective action. Hickmon, et al. v. Fun & Fit LLC, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 152895 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 13, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of home health aides, filed a collective and class action alleging that Defendant violated various provisions of the FLSA and the New York Labor Law (“NYLL”). Plaintiffs filed a motion for conditional certification of a collective action, which the Court denied. In support of their motion, Plaintiffs submitted affidavits outlining the wage & hour violations that they and other home health aides allegedly experienced, as well as Defendants’ shift

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4