18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition
92 Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition associates, stocks associates, cashiers, and all other hourly employees . . . who work or worked for Defendants at any time from May 14, 2017 to the present." Id . at *11. Defendants argued that because they discontinued the Commission Policy on July 1, 2019, Plaintiffs’ request for conditional certification of employees who worked for Defendants after that date was overbroad. Defendants further asserted that Plaintiffs failed to adequately allege that every member of the potential collective action worked "some overtime hours" and thus the scope of collective action was overbroad. Id. The Court agreed with Plaintiffs that they had alleged facts specific enough to warrant conditional certification of a collective action of hourly workers who were employed by Defendants before July 1, 2019, as they sufficiently asserted that they were each subject to a single policy whereby Defendants failed to properly calculate their overtime pay rate by omitting bonus compensation paid to them pursuant to the Commission Policy from the calculation of their regular rate of pay. Id . at *12. Plaintiffs further provided observations from their own personal experiences that these pay policies were the same across multiple store locations. Finally, the Court noted that Defendants conceded that the Commission Policy at issue was in effect at stores across the country, and for several categories of employees. Accordingly, the Court found that conditional certification was warranted, but limited the scope of the collective action as requested by Defendants to only those employed until July 1, 2019, or the date Defendants ceased to pay the commission rate. Id . at *14. Accordingly, the Court granted in part Plaintiffs’ motion for conditional certification of a collective action. Gorzkowska, et al. v. Euro Homecare LLC , 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12037 (D. Conn. Jan. 22, 2021). Plaintiff, a home healthcare provider, filed a collective action alleging that Defendant failed to pay for all hours worked in violation of the FLSA. Plaintiff filed a motion for conditional certification of a collective action, which the Court granted. Home healthcare providers were required to work in the home for 24-hour shifts. During the shift, providers were required to have 3 hour-long breaks during day hours and an 8-hour break for sleep time, which were unpaid. Defendant’s policy therefore provided for 13-hours of paid time and 11-hours unpaid time during each 24-hour shift. Plaintiff contended that he and other providers were regularly required to work during these breaks without pay. Plaintiff sought conditional certification of a collective action of all current and former employees who provided live-in caregiver and/or companion services to Defendant’s clients at any time between November 7, 2016 and the present. Id . at *14-15. In support of the motion, Plaintiff provided his own declaration and the declarations of three other opt-in Plaintiffs. The declarations all asserted that providers gave around-the- clock care and “were subjected to the same policy of requiring live-in homecare workers to falsely report taking three hour-long breaks during each day and having eight uninterrupted hours for sleep each night." Id . at *12. Further, the declarations averred that the providers were directed to submit timesheets indicating that they worked only 13-hours when in fact they worked more hours during a 24-hour period. Defendant argued that it did not have such a policy and Plaintiff failed to prove that Defendant would only pay for 13-hours per shift. The Court rejected Defendant’s argument as going to the merits of the claim, and thus declined to address it at the conditional certification stage. The Court found that Plaintiff’s declarations sufficiently alleged that there were similarly-situated individuals who were subject to a common policy. For these reasons, the Court granted Plaintiff’s motion for conditional certification of a collective action. Han, et al. v. Shang Noodle House, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 159919 (E.D.N.Y. Aug. 24, 2021). Plaintiff, a restaurant employee, filed a collective action alleging that Defendant failed to pay minimum wages and overtime compensation in violation of the FLSA. Plaintiff filed a motion for conditional certification of a collective action, which the Court granted in part and denied in part. Plaintiff sought conditional certification of a collective action consisting of all kitchen employees and servers. In support of his motion, Plaintiff offered his own declaration in which he stated that he and other restaurant employees were required to work 72 hours per week, were only paid a flat rate, and were not provided with overtime compensation for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. Plaintiff specifically averred that he knew of other employees’ payments because of personal conversations he had with them. Plaintiff asserted that he was also aware of the schedules of other kitchen employees because he worked with them. The Court found that Plaintiff made the requisite showing necessary to demonstrate that he was similarly-situated to other kitchen employees for purposes of conditional certification. However, the Court reasoned that Plaintiffs’ affidavit failed to make the showing required to establish that waitstaff employees were also similarly-situated to him. Plaintiff asserted that he knew that waitstaff worked 12 hour days over five days, but also contended that some waitstaff worked different schedules and hours. Accordingly, the Court declined to include waitstaff employees as members within the collective action. The Court further explained that Plaintiff’s
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4