18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition
Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 493 doors in the middle of the Spring 2020 semester and migrated course instruction from in-person classrooms to virtual ones, which resulted in hundreds of lawsuits alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment. As to Defendant’s argument that Plaintiff’s claims must be dismissed because they ran afoul of Connecticut’s educational malpractice doctrine, the Court held that Plaintiff’s claims did not implicate the educational malpractice doctrine because Plaintiff did not challenge the adequacy of the online instruction that he received, but instead the essence of the his claims was that the university promised and failed to provide in-person educational services and to refund his tuition and fees in the event those services could not be provided. However, the Court agreed with Defendant that Plaintiff failed to plausibly allege that the university breached an agreement to provide him an in-person education because the university’s decision to suspend in-person education in light of the COVID-19 pandemic represented an exercise of authority expressly reserved to the university, and the exercise of that authority could not constitute a breach. As such, the Court dismissed Plaintiff’s breach of contract claims. As to the claim for unjust enrichment, the Court agreed with Defendant that Plaintiff’s unjust enrichment claim could not survive because it expressly incorporated his breach of contract claim. As to Plaintiff’s CUTPA claim, Plaintiff was required to allege three elements, including: (i) a representation, omission, or other practice likely to mislead consumers; (ii) the consumers interpreted the message reasonably under the circumstances, and (iii) the misleading representation, omission, or practice was material. Plaintiff’s complaint alleged that Defendant engaged in deceptive practices in violation of CUTPA by falsely representing to Plaintiff and putative class members that online education had the same value as in- person education. The Court concluded that the CUTPA claim was insufficient because the complaint did not identify a single representation or omission that Defendant made regarding the value of the online educational experience that Defendant provided in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. For these reasons, the Court granted Defendant’s motion to dismiss as to Plaintiff’s CUTPA claim as well. In summary, the Court granted Defendant’s Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss in its entirety. Miller, et al. v. Grand Canyon University, Inc. , 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 94800 (N.D. Tex. May 19, 2021). Plaintiff, an online university student, filed a class action alleging claims of fraudulent omission, fraudulent misrepresentation, and unjust enrichment, as well as violations of the Racketeer Influence and Corrupt Organizations ("RICO") Act, the Arizona RICO Act, and the Arizona Consumer Fraud Act ("ACFA") against Defendants. Plaintiff filed a motion for class certification of her claims, which the Court denied. Plaintiff asserted that she applied to Defendants’ online program to obtain her masters’ degree in teaching. Plaintiff contended that she had several calls with Defendants’ admission staff, in which she was assured that the program was accredited in the state and that she would be able to obtaining a teaching certification following graduation. Plaintiff alleged that the representations made to her were false and misleading and that she "would not have enrolled in GCU if she had not been misled about the program." Id . at *5. Plaintiff alleged that she thereafter left the program prior to graduation. Defendants contend that Plaintiff left because she was expelled following the university’s discovery that she failed to disclose her criminal history as part of an FBI background check required by her education curriculum. The Court found that Plaintiff’s proposed class of “all Grand Canyon University students who have been enrolled in an online professional graduate degree or certificate program that is not accredited in the state where they are employed or resided” failed to meet the commonality and typicality requirements of Rule 23(a), and the predominance requirement of Rule 23(b). Id . at *6. Plaintiff proposed six questions common to all putative class members, including: (i) if Defendants knowingly enrolled students in professional programs which were unaccredited in the student’s state; (ii) if Defendants’ practices amounted to fraud or misrepresentation; (iii) if Defendants violated federal law or regulations; (iv) if Arizona law applied; (v) if Defendants were unjustly enriched as a result of their improper conduct; and (vi) the type and level of damages and any equitable remedy to which class members were entitled. Id . at *11. The Court reasoned that providing answers to the proposed questions would fail to produce any evidence for the putative class’s claims. The Court held that determining whether Defendants committed fraud or misrepresentation as to Plaintiff would not establish that Defendants did so for every putative class member. As to typicality, the Court opined that Plaintiff failed to identify any uniform representation or misrepresentation to the proposed class through which to tie her experience to those that others might have had. Id . at *15. Finally, the Court determined that individual questions predominated over common questions, such that class certification was not appropriate. The Court therefore denied Plaintiff’s motion.
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4