18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition

Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 491 in connection with Defendant’s move to online instruction in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic in the Spring of 2020. Defendant filed a motion to dismiss, which the Magistrate Judge recommended be granted. Plaintiff contended that she did not receive the benefit of her bargain, but instead received an inferior product for the second half of the Spring 2020 semester (due to the lack of in-person classes). As to the implied breach of contract claim, Defendant contended that it had an the Financial Responsibility Agreement ("FRA") with Plaintiff, and that Plaintiff’s claim was sounded in in "educational malpractice," which was not cognizable under Texas law. The Magistrate Judge opined that Plaintiff failed to adequately state a viable claim. The Magistrate Judge explained that under Texas law, breach of contract requires pleading and proof that: (i) a valid contract exists; (ii) Plaintiff performed or tendered performance as contractually required; (iii) Defendant breached the contract by failing to perform or tender performance as contractually required; and (iv) Plaintiff sustained damages due to the breach. Id . at *7. The Magistrate Judge reasoned that the FRA was a valid express contract between the parties. The Magistrate Judge also determined that the merger clause contained in the FRA spelled out the contract terms in clear and unambiguous language and, absent language regarding the mode of instruction in the express terms of the instrument, Plaintiff’s objection to remote instruction was merely a preference, and could not give rise to a claim. Id . a t*15. The Magistrate Judge ruled that under Texas law, unjust enrichment is not an independent cause of action, and therefore, disposition of the breach of contract issue required dismissal of the unjust enrichment claim. For these reasons, the Magistrate Judge recommended that Defendant’s motion be granted in its entirety. King, et al. v. Baylor University, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 62160 (W.D. Tex. March 31, 2021). Plaintiff, an undergraduate student, filed a class action alleging claims for implied breach of contract and unjust enrichment in connection with Defendant’s move to online instruction in wake of the COVID-19 pandemic in the Spring of 2020. Defendant filed a motion to dismiss, which the Magistrate Judge previously recommended be granted. On Rule 72 review, the Court adopted the Magistrate Judge’s report and recommendation and granted Defendant’s motion to dismiss. Plaintiff contended that she did not receive the benefit of her bargain, but instead received an inferior product for the second half of the Spring 2020 semester. As to the implied breach of contract claim, Defendant contended that it had an the Financial Responsibility Agreement ("FRA"), and that Plaintiff’s claim was sounded in "educational malpractice," which was not cognizable under Texas law. Id . at *3. The Magistrate Judge opined that Plaintiff failed to adequately state a viable claim. The Magistrate Judge explained that under Texas law, breach of contract requires pleading and proof that: (i) a valid contract exists; (ii) Plaintiff performed, or tendered performance as contractually required; (iii) Defendant breached the contract by failing to perform or tender performance as contractually required; and (iv) Plaintiff sustained damages due to the breach. Id . at *7. The Magistrate Judge reasoned that the FRA was a valid express contract between the parties. The Magistrate Judge also determined that the merger clause contained in the FRA spelled out the contract terms in clear and unambiguous terms, and absent language regarding the mode of instruction in the express terms of the instrument, Plaintiff’s objection to remote instruction was merely a preference, and could not give rise to a claim. Id . a t*15. In addition, the Magistrate Judge opined that under Texas law, unjust enrichment is not an independent cause of action, and therefore, the breach of contract issue required dismissal of rendered the unjust enrichment claim. The Magistrate Judge therefore recommended that Defendant’s motion be granted in its entirety. The Court conducted a de novo review of the motion to dismiss, the report and recommendation, the objections to the report and recommendation, and the applicable law. Following that review, the Court found that the Magistrate Judge’s report and recommendation should be adopted, and it thereby granted Defendant’s motion to dismiss. Little, et al. v. Grand Canyon University , 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 178889 (D. Ariz. Sept. 20, 2022). Plaintiff, a university student, filed a class action alleging claims for breach of contract and unjust enrichment in connection with Defendant’s move to online instruction during the COVID-19 pandemic. Plaintiff filed a motion for class certification pursuant to Rule 23, which the Court denied. Plaintiff sought to bring claims on behalf of two classes, including: (i) those who paid room and board fees to Defendant; and (ii) those who paid fees during the Spring 2020 semester. On March 23, 2020, Defendant announced that limited credits would be offered to students who moved out of their on-campus housing by March 25, 2020, with credits ranging from $260 to $450 based on dorm location and occupancy. Id . at *3. Plaintiff alleged that the credits offered were insufficient because they were not the full-prorated, unused portion of students’ room and board payments. Id . at *4. Defendant also announced that dining credits left in students’ accounts would roll over to the next semester, with

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4