18th Annual Workplace Class Action Report - 2022 Edition
Annual Workplace Class Action Litigation Report: 2022 Edition 487 Court determined that Plaintiff could not plausibly allege that the decision to move to online learning was not reasonable based on the circumstances. The Court also opined that even if it analyzed the claim for tuition as an ordinary contract claim, it would fail under the terms of the Enrollment Agreement. The Court noted that the broad release in the Agreement allowing Defendant "the right to alter . . . curriculum content," without requiring that Defendant provide a refund. Id . at *14. The Court therefore ruled that Defendant was within its discretion to make the changes required to move to online instruction, and thus granted Defendant’s motion to dismiss the breach of contract claims for tuition reimbursement. In addition, the Court noted that Plaintiff also paid registration, student, and technology fees. The Agreement stated multiple times that the registration fee was non-refundable, and therefore the Court granted Defendant’s motion as to the registration fee. However, the Court found that Plaintiff asserted a plausible breach of contract claim as to the student fee because the Agreement entitled him to a refund "based upon use." Id . at *18. Thus, by refusing to refund Plaintiff any amount of those fees, the Court held that Defendant breached its obligation to provide some pro-rated amount, and Plaintiff suffered damages because he did not receive a partial refund he would be entitled to under the Agreement. The Court also determined that it was plausible that the claim could be an unjust enrichment claim, as therefore proceeding as a dual pleading would be appropriate here because it was not yet clear whether Defendant may be able to defeat an express contract claim. Accordingly, the Court granted in part and denied in part Defendant’s motion to dismiss. Gibson, et al. v. Lynn University, Inc. , 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 54324 (S.D. Fla. March 23, 2021). Plaintiff, an undergraduate student, filed a putative class action alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment in connection with Defendant’s closure of on-campus living and services during the COVID-19 pandemic. Defendant filed a motion to dismiss, or in the alternative, to strike Plaintiff’s class claims. The Court denied the motion. Plaintiff’s proposed class consisted of “All persons who paid, on behalf of themselves or another, tuition or fees for in-person education in the Undergraduate Day Division or Graduate Division at Lynn University for the Spring 2020 term.” Id . at *5. Defendant argued that Plaintiff’s claims should be dismissed for several reasons, including: (i) each student’s expectations over whether they would receive in person education and whether an actual contract governed those expectations would lead to individualized inquires; (ii) finding damages would be individualized because “loss of experience” was inherently subjective; (iii) under Eleventh Circuit precedent, unjust enrichment claims were unsuitable for class treatment; and (iv) many individuals in the proposed class lacked standing. Id . The Court determined that the extreme remedies of dismissing or striking Plaintiff’s class allegations were not warranted. The Court determined that Plaintiff asserted sufficient facts to fulfill the Rule 23 requirements, and alleged several questions common to the class. The Court reasoned that at this early stage in the litigation, it was not clear solely form the pleadings that the nature of the parties’ contractual relationship would not be susceptible to class-wide proof based on the publications, policies, and other materials that Defendant provided to its students, or that they would require individual inquiries. Id . at *14. The Court ruled that the individualized damages issues were not so extreme as to preclude class certification at the pleadings stage, particularly considering Plaintiff’s representation that he "can and will present a class-wide impact and damages model" to support his motion for class certification. Id . at *15. As to class treatment of the unjust enrichment claim, the Court noted that given the fact that the alleged contract was the exact same between each putative class member and Defendant, i.e. , the cost of the semester of tuition, it was not obvious from the pleadings that there were significant equitable differences among the class members. Finally, the Court found that Plaintiff met all the standing requirements, and the fact that some putative class members may be determined to lack standing in the future did not warrant dismissal. For these reasons, the Court denied Defendant’s motion to dismiss, or to strike the class allegations. Gociman, et al. v. Loyola University Of Chicago, 2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 13238 (N.D. Ill. Jan. 25, 2021). Plaintiffs, a group of college students and parents of undergraduate students, filed a class action alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment in connection with Defendant closing in-person learning offerings due to the disaster proclamation issued by the Illinois Governor on account of the COVID-19 pandemic. Plaintiffs alleged that Defendant’s website, brochures, course catalogues, and online registration portal established a contractual promise to provide in-person instruction and access to facilities and resources. Further, Plaintiffs contended without in person class instruction and access to campus facilities and events, the cost of their education was worth significantly less. Defendant moved to dismiss for lack of standing under Rule 12(b)(1), and for failure to state a claim under Rule 12(b)(6). As to the standing argument, Defendant contended that as parents of adult
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy OTkwMTQ4